Mystery Shopping FAQs For Newbies & Beginners

By Melanie Jordan, author of “The Perfect Work-At-Home Job: Mystery Shopping” and “How-To Finally Make Money As A Mystery Shopper”  

Is mystery shopping for real?  

Mystery shopping is one of the few things out there in the sea of work-at-home junk that is legitimate.  I wouldn't waste my time with it if it was not something I had a positive experience with and knew that others could too.  However, it can either be the road to overworked and underpaid, or if you do it right, it can be quite lucrative for a work-at-home, legitimate, flexible job. I have learned how to do it the second way of course!

How do I know which companies are legitimate?

If you look at the different shopper boards, you'll see the same companies listed again and again.  You will also see shoppers put up notes if someone is not paying or there are other problems—word gets around fast in this industry!  Another way is to see if the company is a member of the National Mystery Shopping Providers Association (www.mysteryshop.org), many of the larger ones are.  A final check can be with the Better Business Bureau (www.bbb.org) to see if any complaints have been registered against the company before you do work for them.   

Most companies, like The Secret Shopper Company are legitimate—however, if anyone asks you for upfront money to register to do shops for them, you can pretty much assume it’s a scam.  

What are some of the advantages of being a mystery shopper?  

Flexibility—make money when you want to on your terms, and don’t when you have other things to do!  The ability to be home-based (except when you are out in the field actually doing your research) is another great benefit.

Plus, while you can earn nice money on a regular basis, you can also get lots of things for free that you might otherwise have to pay for out of your own pocket.  By doing mystery shopping, you can actually make your household budget go further, and possibly get to do things (like go out to a fancy restaurant), you would not otherwise get to do as often, with someone else footing the bill.  

Finally, since mystery shoppers are typically independent contractors, this can have substantial tax advantages over being a W-2 employee—check with your tax advisor.  

Who does mystery shopping?  

Mystery shopping is for all kinds of people who want the freedom to be home-based without set working hours so they can make money when they want to, and not bother when they have other things to do—like living their life!  There are mystery shopping seniors, stay-at-home Moms and Dads, college students, employment seekers and career changers, entrepreneurs looking for another income stream while they get their business launched and creative people (actors, writers, etc.).    

What kind of experience do I need?  Does previous work experience/education help me in any way?

You don't need any specific experience to be a mystery shopper.  Since so much of it is on-line based, it is important to be good with e-mail and working with attachments, and have basic word processing and spreadsheet skills (data entry, not spreadsheet creation).  You should also have good communication skills—both writing (although you don't have to be at the level of winning a Pulitzer), and the ability to carry on a conversation with employees of businesses you will be interacting with in doing your assignments.  Personal qualities like being observant, reliable and having a good imagination are also very important to be a top mystery shopper.

That said, an initial plus (until you get actual mystery shopping experience) would be any prior work experience or education in retail, financial services or apartment leasing (since many shops fall into these industries), customer service or the field of market research.  But if you don't have any prior "credits" in these areas, don't worry.  It won't keep you from being a mystery shopper if you present yourself the right way.

Can I do mystery shopping if I have a baby or small children?  

Here’s a special note for stay-at-home Moms and Dads—this is actually a job where you can often bring along well-behaved kids.  While you can't bring the kids on every assignment, enough companies will allow it and for some shops like day care centers, gyms with babysitting or toy stores, it could be required.  Every assignment always has specifics on what dates and times it can be completed, so you know before you accept or apply for the job if it is something you can do.  

So what do mystery shoppers really do?  

Basically, depending upon the type of shop or research assignment, a mystery shopper, secret shopper, researcher, or most commonly referred to as simply “shopperwill pretend in a believable fashion, without giving away the fact they are a shopper, to be an actual customer or potential customer of a business.  In the process, the shopper will gather information and make observations that the client company wants to know about, and submit a report with their objective findings later on.  

You may be asked to pretend you are looking for an apartment; interested in joining a gym; looking for a new bank to open a checking account; or even buying a piano.  Your job may be to rent a video; bring your car in for repair; go out to lunch; go grocery shopping; etc.  You could be asked to call a mail order house and evaluate its service, or even to check out a company’s web site and see how easy you find it to use.

Almost any type of business—big or small, well-known chain or not—can use mystery shopping services.  The types of shops you do can be as varied as you like, or you may decide to specialize only in certain kinds based upon your own personal preferences and the pay or work involved.  

How much can I make for each assignment?  

If you do higher-paying service category shops (such as apartments, home builders, car dealers, testing centers, gyms, oil changes, banks), you can typically make between $20 and $30 per assignment, or a dinner restaurant shop can pay $35-$100 in free food/drinks.  Retail assignments typically pay less ($7 to $15), although a “purchase and return shop” can get you up to $25.  Fast food shops pay the least—often just free food and possibly a $5 report fee.  Shop fees earned vary depending upon where you live, market demand and how urgent the job is.   

An assignment can take as little as a half hour of your time including filling out a report, to two hours.  The more you are asked to do, the more the assignment pays.  If you focus on the highest-paying assignments, make the right connections and create a system where you get the jobs coming to you, you’ll become a top-earning mystery shopper.  

How much can I make a month?  

Just like any self-employed person, you should expect your income will fluctuate from month-to-month.  If there is a good demand for mystery shoppers in your area, and you have plenty of time available to you, it is entirely possible to make up to $1,000 in a month’s time in actual cash and high-end freebies depending upon the types of assignments you do.  Many good mystery shoppers earn $300 to $600 extra per month once they are experienced.  People who “dabble” in mystery shopping make $200 or less per month.  But you don’t want to be a dabbler, you want to be a top-earning mystery shopper!  

If I live in a small town should I give up on the idea of being a mystery shopper?

Not at all! While it is true that the opportunities in your small town may be somewhat limited (although it depends by what you mean by small), if you live near a sizable city, you should be able to get assignments.  Otherwise, you’ll still get jobs, but not as many.  

Your earnings as a mystery shopper are somewhat dictated by market demand for those services.  However, it can also be a quality vs. quantity thing.  I have seen some requests for mystery shoppers in smaller areas with much higher than normal pay or bonuses attached because there were assignments available and companies were having trouble finding a shopper to do them.  So you might do very well even if you do less assignments than someone like me in a pretty major market like Southern California.  

How do I get started in finding mystery shopping assignments in my city or state?  

1.  Sign up with The Secret Shopper Company—they are one of the best!  They have assignments nationwide and will let you know by e-mail when there is something available in your area and invite you to request the job.  

2.  At my resource center, Mystery Shopping Coach’s Corner there is a link at the bottom of that page to check out one of my favorite mystery shopping lead resources called "Mystery Shoppers Resources".  It can be found at http://mysteryshopcoach.cjb.net.  The webmaster, Julie Moreau will even send you an e-mail alert when she updates the page (email to jmoreau1@aol.com and please mention I referred you).

3.  Delphi and Topica newsgroups have some state-specific lead boards.  You might try there at www.delphi.com or www.topica.com.   

There’s a lot more to being a professional, top-earning mystery shopper than just this, but it’s a way for you to dabble and get a feel for what is possible. The key to earning top money as a mystery shopper is to work efficiently because time spent looking for work is time spent not working (and earning money)!  You need to make the right connections and ultimately have jobs coming to you.  

About Melanie Jordan  

Besides being a veteran mystery shopper, Melanie is the author of two books on mystery shopping—“The Perfect Work-At-Home Job: Mystery Shopping” and “How-To Finally Make Money As A Mystery Shopper."  She also provides personal coaching services to beginning and experienced shoppers by phone and e-mail.   

Her free monthly e-zine for mystery shoppers is called “The Perfect Work-At-Home Job Update” (subscribe by e-mail to mysteryshopcoach@aol.com).  Back issues of this e-zine are available exclusively at her web site Mystery Shopping Coach’s Corner http://www.mysteryshoppercoach.com.

Copyright 2003, Melanie R. Jordan E-Publishing